Causation is an issue for the purpose of Intermediate Track Complexity Banding (even where Liability is admitted)

SIGN UP TO OUR FREE COSTS NEWSLETTER

In the matter of Ms Donna Thompson v Micronclean Ltd (County Court at York) (13 October 2026) it was determined that, in an Intermediate Track claim, an admission of liability does not mean there is only one issue in dispute where both causation and quantum remain contested for the purpose of Table 2 in CPR 26 and assignment of complexity band.

This is an important distinction because it meant that such a claim would not be suitable for Complexity Band 1 on the Intermediate Track. Practitioners operating within the Intermediate Track will be well aware of the significant disparity in recoverable costs between Complexity Band 1 and the higher bands.

Carter Burnett were instructed for the purpose of the costs litigation by Marisha Lowe of Ringrose Law who represented the claimant in the successful substantive action.

 

Speed-Read

For those seeking a speed read:

1) Where a claim settles pre-allocation and assignment then the parties must agree the track and band, absent agreement the court can be asked to determine the same.

2) In the matter at hand the Intermediate Track was agreed but not the banding. The defendant contended that as liability had been admitted there was only one issue in dispute as such Complexity Band 1 was appropriate. The claimant submitted that, although liability had been admitted, causation and quantum remained distinct issues in dispute, rendering the claim unsuitable for Complexity Band 1. The claimant argued that Complexity Band 2 was appropriate.

3) The court accepted the claimant’s position, holding that there were two issues to be resolved and that alone would take the matter out of CB1.

4) The operation of complexity banding on the IMT is such that the higher the band, the higher the recoverable costs. Moreover, there is a general recognition that the costs in CB1 are low and the jump to even just CB2 is significant. The claimant here recovered more than 2.5 times in costs than those prescribed under CB1.

5) There will continue to be arguments as to both allocation and banding. Table 1, Part 26 (Fast Track) and Table 2, Part 26 (Intermediate Track) give definitions for each band and highlight several areas of ambiguity and discretion.

 

The Background

The claim arose from an accident at work that resulted in personal injury.  The matter settled pre-issue so the claim was unallocated and unassigned. The parties agreed that the matter was suitable for the Intermediate Track but could not agree on the Complexity Banding.

The Law

CPR 26, Table 2 provides a table which details how claims will normally be assigned on the Intermediate Track. There has been considerable debate regarding how these provisions should operate and be interpreted.

One particularly contentious point is that Complexity Band 1 is said to apply to any claim where:

a) There is only one issue in dispute; and

b) The trial is not expected to last longer than one day including personal injury claims where liability or quantum is in dispute, road traffic accident related, non-personal injury claims and defended debt claims.

Where a claim settles pre-allocation and assignment then the parties must seek to agree the prospective allocation and banding. Where this is not possible then the court may be asked to determine the matter.

 

The Arguments

The defendant contended that as liability had been admitted there was only one issue in dispute and as such the claim was suitable for Intermediate Track, Complexity Band 1.

The claimant’s position was that:

a) Liability had been admitted but causation had not and as such both causation and quantum were in dispute and this would constitute more than one issue in dispute.

b) That the claim would have, in any event, required a trial exceeding 1-day.

c) That the claim was too complex for Band 1.

The claimant argued that the claim should be assigned to Intermediate Track Complexity Band 2.

 

The Court’s Decision

District Judge MacCuish considered the matter and determined that the matter was suitable for the Intermediate Track Complexity Band 2. They set out their reasoning as follows:

a) “Complexity Band 1 is the appropriate band for a claim where there is, amongst other matters, only one issue in dispute […]”

b) “The defendant’s solicitor’s email of 9 June 2025, by which the defendant admitted liability, but then stated that the defendant did not agree as to the, “extent or causation injuries”.”

c) “The court regards that email of 9 June 2025 as being determinative of the ambit of the dispute and complexity. The defendant’s later email of 8 October 2025 in which it repeats its earlier statement that liability is admitted (but with no further qualification to that statement), and then references the accompanying financial settlement offer, does not serve to define the ambit of the dispute nor assist with determining complexity”

d) “Accordingly, with liability admitted, there were two principal issues to be resolved in the case; causation, and quantum. That alone takes the matter out of Intermediate Track complexity band 1 as contended for by the defendant, and into complexity band 2 as contended for by the claimant”

Having concluded that causation and quantum constituted separate issues, the court found it was unnecessary to determine the remaining arguments concerning trial length or overall complexity.

The claimant was awarded its costs of the Fixed Costs Determination.

 

What does this mean in practice?

The decision highlights an acceptance by the court that causation is to be treated as a separate issue. In practical terms, a defendant may not be able to secure Complexity Band 1 merely by admitting liability where causation remains contested.

It also means that the court can apply its discretion as to which banding (CB2, 3 or 4) applies depending on the specific facts and complexities of the case.

The decision is consistent with Sir Rupert Jackson's view that Complexity Bands 2 and 3 would represent the 'normal' banding for Intermediate Track cases.

Assignment (of a Complexity Band) is a significant factor in calculating Fixed Recoverable Costs on the Intermediate Track. The higher the complexity band, the higher the recoverable costs. The difference between Bands 1 and 2 is particularly significant and should not be underestimated.

By way of example a claim settling pre-issue on Complexity Band 1 would provide FRC of £1,652 + 3% of damages whilst the same claim on Complexity Band 2 would attract FRC of £5,162 + 6% of damages. A case concluding at Trial on IMT CB1 would give applicable costs of £6,813 + 15% of damages + Advocacy fees whilst on IMT CB2 this would be £17,550 + 20% of damages + advocacy fees.

Decisions of this nature can also have wider implications for access to justice and the economic viability of pursuing certain claims.

Disputes concerning complexity banding are likely to remain common as the case law continues to develop. However, this decision makes clear that there is an important distinction between admitting liability and accepting causation. That distinction should be considered carefully when assessing the appropriate band and, consequently, the level of recoverable costs. Such arguments bear consideration in pre-allocation costs disputes but also to matters which face allocation and assignment disputes post-issue.

We would pass on our thanks and gratitude to Marisha Lowe at Ringrose for her instructions in this matter.

We are always happy to discuss any aspect of costs. If you have any questions or concerns arising from this article then please get in touch for an informal chat - call 01482 534567 or email info@carterburnett.co.uk

Next
Next

Part 36 Late Acceptance and Fixed Recoverable Costs